One Republican bashed him as “pro-criminal.” One other referred to as him a “horrible” prosecutor with a behavior of shedding instances. A 3rd advised he was within the pocket of a rich Jewish financier steadily demonized by the far proper.
“He ought to resign and be disbarred,” declared Consultant Jeff Van Drew, Republican of New Jersey.
Two weeks after Alvin L. Bragg, the Manhattan district legal professional, introduced 34 legal costs in opposition to former President Donald J. Trump, Home Republicans descended on his residence turf on Monday to carry a listening to attacking Mr. Bragg’s report on crime, leveling exaggerated and generally outright false costs.
Consultant Jim Jordan, Republican of Ohio and the chairman of the Judiciary Committee, convened his panel on the Jacob Okay. Javits Federal Constructing to listen to from an array witnesses who’ve been outspoken critics of Mr. Bragg for a session that was ostensibly about crime in New York Metropolis however whose unmistakable subtext was an effort to tarnish the person who’s prosecuting Mr. Trump.
The outcome was a bitterly adversarial listening to that unfolded in a carnival-like ambiance, drawing offended protesters from the left and the precise who hoisted indicators and hurled invective that was solely barely extra vitriolic than the talk between Democratic and Republican lawmakers.
At one level, Consultant Hank Johnson, Democrat of Georgia, chastised Republicans for touring to New York to go after Mr. Bragg, saying they have been behaving like “jackbooted thugs.”
A single elected official almost certainly has little sway over crime traits in a serious metropolitan space, and crime in Manhattan, the place Mr. Bragg took workplace in January 2022, is down from final 12 months by about 2.four p.c — although it stays up considerably from two years in the past.
Nonetheless, Republicans used particular person crime victims to attempt to impeach his report. One after the other, the witnesses invited by Republicans instructed private horror tales of their encounters with crime within the metropolis, together with struggling an antisemitic assault and shedding a cherished one in a brutal stabbing. The witnesses described New York — the place crime has plummeted in latest many years however spiked in the course of the pandemic, as in different cities — as being in a state of decay, and blamed Mr. Bragg’s insurance policies.
“We obtained no assist from his workplace,” stated Madeline Brame, the chairwoman of the Victims Rights Reform Council and the mom of a murder sufferer who for months has taken difficulty with the district legal professional. “It was a horrific expertise.”
Democrats pushed again in opposition to the Republican effort to vilify Mr. Bragg whereas laboring to indicate sympathy for the victims.
“I concern that you’re getting used for a political objective, regardless of your sincerity,” stated Consultant Zoe Lofgren, Democrat of California, prompting objections from the witnesses.
The listening to got here every week after Mr. Bragg filed a lawsuit in opposition to Mr. Jordan in search of to cease congressional Republicans from interfering in his case in opposition to Mr. Trump — the product of an almost five-year investigation that started below his predecessor — and particularly, to bar them from deposing Mark F. Pomerantz, a lawyer who labored on the inquiry for a few 12 months.
On Monday, because the congressional listening to was getting underway, a lawyer for Mr. Jordan filed a response to Mr. Bragg’s lawsuit, saying that it represented “a rare and unconstitutional” try and have a choose intrude in a congressional inquiry.
A lawyer for Mr. Bragg declined to touch upon Mr. Jordan’s response.
The listening to was repeatedly interrupted by protesters and outbursts. At one level, a bunch loudly tried entry into the listening to room, chanting, “Allow us to in!” They held indicators that stated “Jim Jordan, Insurrectionist,” referring to the Ohio Republican’s function in planning the efforts in Congress on Jan. 6, 2021, to overturn the election outcomes, and “34 felonies,” a reference to the fees in opposition to Mr. Trump.
Antisemitism was on vivid show. Outdoors the Javits constructing, a person held an indication with the identify of the financier George Soros, a Jewish Holocaust survivor, together with the picture of a Star of David and greenback indicators. A number of Republicans contained in the listening to room additionally targeted their feedback on Mr. Soros, whom they blamed for supporting the campaigns of progressive prosecutors, together with Mr. Bragg’s.
“With antisemitic tropes emanating from Home Republicans, it’s unsurprising, however no much less vile, to see the Republicans bringing this antisemitism to New York exterior in the present day’s stunt listening to in Manhattan,” stated Consultant Jerrold Nadler of New York, the highest Democrat on the committee.
Chaos erupted because the lawmakers left, with anti-Bragg protesters jeering.
Contained in the listening to room, Democrats and Republicans engaged in a heated dispute over the state of crime in New York and across the nation.
Main crime is down barely in New York this 12 months in contrast with the identical interval final 12 months, according to the latest statistics. However, as in cities across the nation, New York noticed a pointy enhance in murders and shootings in the course of the coronavirus pandemic. There was a rise in main crimes final 12 months in New York, however murders, shootings and different crimes have continued to drop.
Mr. Bragg has referred to New York because the “most secure massive metropolis in America” and emphasised that its crime charge is decrease than cities within the states of lots of his Republican critics, together with Columbus, Ohio, simply south of Mr. Jordan’s district.
“How will we transfer the venue so we are able to have a listening to in a metropolis or state that has a critical crime drawback — the state of Ohio,” stated Consultant David Cicilline, Democrat of Rhode Island.
Republicans stated Mr. Bragg, who introduced upon taking workplace final 12 months that he would not be prosecuting certain misdemeanor crimes — however later revised these insurance policies amid a backlash — had prompted a criminal offense spree.
“Think about that,” Mr. Jordan stated. “You allow criminals on the road, you get extra crime.”
A spokeswoman for Mr. Bragg fired again in an announcement: “For outdoor politicians to now seem in New York Metropolis on the taxpayer dime for a political stunt is a slap within the face to the devoted N.Y.P.D. officers, prosecutors and different public servants who work tirelessly every single day with information and knowledge to maintain our residence secure.”
For a lot of the listening to, Republicans averted mentioning Mr. Trump’s identify, in search of to maintain the give attention to crime in New York.
However Consultant Chip Roy, Republican of Texas, made the connection as he argued that Mr. Bragg had no enterprise prosecuting Mr. Trump.
“Was it former President Trump that killed your son?” he requested one sufferer. “Was it former President Trump that killed your beloved?” he requested one other.
